La Paz Whale Shark Tours

Every winter, young whale sharks gather in the shallow water off El Mogote, a sandbar across the bay from the Malecón. A panga gets you there in minutes, and you slip in with a mask while a spotted fish the length of a bus filters plankton beside you. We compared the three swims that cover every way of doing it, from a small group led by a marine biologist to a full day out of Los Cabos. Each price sits below next to its catch.

  • Whale shark season: roughly November to AprilThe sharks come for the plankton in the bay. Outside those months the boats stop running the swims
  • Swim early in your stayWinter winds can close the bay to small boats for a day or two, so leave yourself a spare morning

In a hurry? Our top pick is Eco Migrations' small-group swim with a marine biologist: ~$187 a person, a full wetsuit and a boat of about eight. You learn what you are looking at before you get in. Book it here.

Whale shark swims at a glance

  • A morning, not a whole dayFrom La Paz a swim takes three to four hours door to door. Coming from Cabo turns it into about ten
  • Small boats, small groupsPangas with up to ten guests, and only a handful of swimmers in the water with the guide at any time
  • Right off the townThe whale shark area lies in the bay off El Mogote, a short boat ride from the Malecón of La Paz
  • Likely in season, never promisedThese are wild animals in a protected area. Wind and murky water decide some days for you

If you only have a minute

Which La Paz whale shark swim should you book?

If a friend asked us how to swim with whale sharks in Baja, this is what we would tell them over a coffee on the Malecón.

The best whale shark tour in La Paz for most visitors is Eco Migrations' biologist-led swim, from ~$187. It keeps the boat small, lends you a full wetsuit for the cool winter water, and puts a marine biologist in the water with you who explains the sharks and the rules.

On a tighter budget, Mexico Travel Adventure's three-hour swim costs ~$123 from the pier on the Malecón and sends you in five at a time. Staying in Los Cabos with no car? Cabo Adventures' day trip at ~$259 picks you up at your hotel and adds a taco lunch in La Paz, at the cost of about five hours on the road.

No tour can promise a shark. Check what each swim costs and which months the sharks are in, see how the morning runs, then read what the listings play down before you pay.

Our pick

The whale shark swim we would book: Eco Migrations, biologist on board

Not the cheapest boat in the bay. It is the one that keeps the group small, keeps you warm in the water, and tells you what you are swimming next to.

A snorkeler in a full wetsuit swimming close beside the spotted back of a whale shark in green water Our pick

La Paz: Whale Shark Swimming Adventure with Marine Biologist, Eco Migrations

★★★★★ 4.9 from 40+ reviews on GetYourGuide · free cancellation up to 24 hours before

Eco Migrations is a small La Paz outfit that builds its trips around naturalist guides. You start at its office in the center of town, where you are fitted with a complete snorkel kit and a full wetsuit. A short boat ride then takes you to the protected whale shark area in the bay.

On the way out, the bilingual marine biologist guide scans the water for the dark shape and the dorsal fin. When a shark is spotted, you slip in with the guide and swim alongside it. Between swims there is time for questions about how the sharks feed and why they come to La Paz at all.

Price
from ~$187 per person
Duration
About 4 hours
Group
Small, about 8 per boat
Guide
Bilingual marine biologist
Start
Eco Migrations office, Zona Central
Kit
Snorkel kit and full wetsuit
Not for
Pregnant women, babies under 1
Cancellation
Free up to 24 hours before

Live availability and prices on GetYourGuide

Powered by GetYourGuide

How the morning runs, step by step

The start time can shift with the day and the wind, so check it on the listing. The outline stays the same:

In town

  • Meet at the Eco Migrations office in the center of La Paz
  • Get fitted for a mask, fins and a full wetsuit
  • A short ride to the boat and out across the bay

In the whale shark area

  • The guide spots a shark and briefs the group on the rules
  • Slip in with the biologist and swim alongside, then back on board between turns
  • Back on land about four hours after the start

What the price covers

The ticket pays for the warm kit and the expert in the water. What it leaves out is mostly the tip and the shark itself.

Included
  • Snorkel kit and a full wetsuit
  • A bilingual marine biologist guide
  • Transport between the office and the boat
  • A small group in the boat
Not included
  • Tips for the crew
  • Getting to the office from your hotel
  • Food and drinks
  • A guarantee of a shark

Between us, before you go

A word from one snorkeler to another. The water in midwinter feels cool after the second swim, and the full wetsuit is the reason we put this boat first. Kick slowly beside the shark rather than chasing it, because it moves faster than it looks and you will tire before it does.

Bring a towel and a windproof layer for the ride back. Our packing list for the boat covers the rest.

Why it beats the cheaper swim

The budget swim from the pier puts you in the same water, and its reviews are excellent. What you pay extra for here is the wetsuit, the smaller boat, and a guide who is a trained biologist and explains what you are seeing. For a first swim, or for anyone nervous in open water, that difference shows. Kids and beginners goes into it.

Who we would not send on it

Travelers counting every peso, who will be just as happy on Mexico Travel Adventure's three-hour swim. Anyone staying in Los Cabos without a car, who should look at the Cabo Adventures day trip with hotel pickup. And pregnant travelers, for whom the listing says the trip is not suitable.

Book it if

You want a small group and a full wetsuit for the cool winter water. You like having a biologist explain the sharks, and you are staying in La Paz or can get there for the morning. It suits first-timers and families, and curious travelers too.

Skip it if

Ready for a morning in the bay?

The swim is on GetYourGuide and on Viator. GetYourGuide shows the higher score, and both let you cancel for free up to 24 hours before, so you can watch the wind forecast before you commit.

The swim itself

How a La Paz whale shark tour works

Every trip on this page answers two questions differently. Will you start in La Paz and be back for lunch, or ride in from Los Cabos for the day? And do you want a biologist and a wetsuit, or the plainest swim at the lowest price?

Style · a morning from La Paz

Out into the bay and back

Eco Migrations, Mexico Travel Adventure

3–4 htown, a short panga ride, turns in the water, back on land

You walk or take a taxi to the start and are done by early afternoon. The boats stay inside the bay, so the ride is short and the water is calmer than the open sea. The rest of the day is free for Balandra or the Malecón.

Style · a day trip from Los Cabos

Desert road, then the sharks

Cabo Adventures

About 10 hhotel pickup, about 2.5 h each way, the swim, lunch in La Paz

Someone else does the driving and the planning, and lunch comes with it. It costs about twice as much as a swim booked in La Paz and spends half the day in a vehicle. If the wind closes the bay, the whole day is gone.

La Paz whale sharks and weather, month by month

  • Rough odds of whale sharks in the bay
  1. Jan23°C high73 °F

    Sharks in, coolest water of the year

  2. Feb24°C high75 °F

    Still prime, wear the full wetsuit

  3. Mar26°C high79 °F

    Warmer days, sharks usually still around

  4. Apr28°C high82 °F

    The season winds down

  5. May31°C high88 °F

    Swims mostly stop for the summer

  6. Jun33°C high91 °F

    Off season, sea lions instead

  7. Jul35°C high95 °F

    Hot, humid, no whale shark swims

  8. Aug35°C high95 °F

    Hottest weeks and storm risk

  9. Sep34°C high93 °F

    Peak of the hurricane months

  10. Oct32°C high90 °F

    Some operators start mid-month

  11. Nov28°C high82 °F

    The season opens, warm water still

  12. Dec24°C high75 °F

    Prime months, busy around the holidays

Temperatures are rough daytime highs in La Paz; on a fast panga in the morning it feels cooler, and the water in midwinter sits around 20–22 °C (68–72 °F). The bars are our rough reading of the listings and the season, not a forecast: wild sharks come and go. Highlighted months are the ones we would pick. The season in detail.

How each trip is spent

  • Getting there and back
  • On the boat, in the whale shark area
  • Lunch and free time

Hours come from the listings; the split between the ride and the time in the whale shark area is approximate, because the crew waits for its turn and searches until a shark turns up. Swimmers take turns in small groups, so the time you spend in the water is a fraction of the time on the boat.

  1. Watch the wind forecastStrong northerly winds in winter can keep the small boats in port. Book a cancellable ticket and decide close to the day. If the bay closes.
  2. Go early in your tripA spare morning lets a windy day move without wrecking your plans. The months and the odds.
  3. Learn the rules firstKeep your distance, never touch, no flash. The guide briefs you, but it helps to know why. The rules in the zone.
  4. Practise with the maskTen minutes in a hotel pool makes the first swim calmer, especially for kids. For nervous swimmers.

Day trip from Cabo or stay in La Paz? weighs the long day with pickup against a night or two in town. It also covers when the day trip is the smarter choice.

How to choose

How to pick the right whale shark swim

The sharks are the same for all three. What differs is where you start, what you wear in the water, and who explains it all.

Where you stay

In La Paz, book a morning swim from town. In Los Cabos without a car, the day trip saves you the drive. Cabo or La Paz.

Group size

Eco Migrations keeps about eight per boat, Mexico Travel Adventure and Cabo Adventures take up to ten. How turns work.

Wetsuit

Eco Migrations and Cabo Adventures list wetsuits; the budget swim lists snorkel gear only. What to bring.

No sharks?

Nobody can promise one. If the operator cancels for wind you get a new date or a refund. When the sharks don't show.

The guide

A marine biologist on two of the three. That matters most for first-timers and curious kids. Why the sharks come here.

Price

From ~$123 a person for the budget swim to ~$259 for the day from Cabo with lunch. Every price in one table.

Everything else to do in La Paz

The 3 tours

Three ways into the water with a whale shark, side by side

We read every La Paz whale shark listing on both booking sites and kept only the ones with real reviews on both. Each card gives the price and the length along with the tour company. It also names the catch, with a button for each site that sells it.

A snorkeler seen from below, silhouetted at the surface above the dark shape of a whale shark Our pick

La Paz: Whale Shark Swimming Adventure with Marine Biologist, Eco Migrations

The one we would book for a first swim.

A small-group trip from Eco Migrations' office in the center of La Paz, with a complete snorkel kit and a full wetsuit. A bilingual marine biologist guides you in the water and explains the sharks between swims.

  • Rating4.9 from 40+ reviews on GetYourGuide
  • DurationAbout 4 hours
  • Tour companyEco Migrations
  • Free cancellationUp to 24 hours before
  • StrengthsSmall boat; full wetsuit; biologist guide
  • Ideal forFirst-timers and families, or anyone curious about the sharks

Good to know: It costs more than the budget swim, and you make your own way to the office. Tips are not included. Viator lists it too, at 4.7 from 50+ reviews. Prices compared.

~$187per person
A whale shark swimming head-on at the surface with its wide mouth open in green water Lowest price

Swim with Whale Sharks in La Paz, Mexico Travel Adventure

The plain, cheap swim with perfect scores.

About three hours from the Muelle Fiscal on the Malecón, out to the whale shark area by El Mogote and back. Swimmers go in five at a time so that everyone gets proper turns, with snorkel gear and a marine biologist guide.

  • Rating5.0 from 50+ reviews on Viator, 5.0 from 40+ on GetYourGuide
  • DurationAbout 3 hours
  • Tour companyMexico Travel Adventure
  • Free cancellationUp to 24 hours before
  • StrengthsLowest price; groups of five in the water; meets at the pier
  • Ideal forBudget travelers and confident swimmers

Good to know: The kit list names snorkel gear and water, but no wetsuit, pickup or food. Bring a towel and a jacket as the listing suggests. What to bring.

~$123per person
A snorkeler floating at the surface above a whale shark in clear turquoise water Most reviewed

La Paz Whale Shark Snorkeling Tour and Lunch from Los Cabos, Cabo Adventures

The no-car answer for a Cabo stay.

A full day that starts with hotel pickup in Los Cabos and about two and a half hours through the desert to La Paz. A traditional panga takes you to the sharks, with wetsuits, life jackets and snorkel gear, then a Baja-style taco lunch and free time in town.

  • Rating4.9 from 1,100+ reviews on Viator
  • DurationAbout 10 hours
  • Tour companyCabo Adventures
  • Free cancellationUp to 24 hours before
  • StrengthsHotel pickup; lunch included; the most reviews by far
  • Ideal forCabo stays without a car, families who want it all arranged

Good to know: About five hours of the day are on the road, and it costs about twice a swim booked in La Paz. Tips and the photo CD are optional extras. Cabo or La Paz.

~$259per person

A small heads-up. These are GetYourGuide and Viator affiliate links, so when you book through one we earn a little commission and you pay exactly the same. It keeps this guide going and never touches our ranking or the catches we point out.

Before you go

Eight things about whale shark swims that no listing puts in big letters

None of these sits at the top of a booking page, and each one decides whether you come home with a shark on your phone or a cold, choppy morning.

What you should know

  1. Wind beats everything. A calm morning is worth more than any other detail. Winter northerlies can close the port to small boats, so keep your booking cancellable. When the bay closes.
  2. The water is green for a reason. The plankton that feeds the sharks also clouds the water. Visibility can be a few meters, so the shark appears close and suddenly. Why they come here.
  3. Boats take turns. The area is regulated and only a few boats work it at once. Some waiting is part of the morning. The rules in the zone.
  4. Winter water feels cool. Around 20–22 °C (68–72 °F) in midwinter is fine for one swim and chilly by the fourth. A full wetsuit helps. What to bring.
  5. You swim at the surface. No diving down and no scuba. Strong swimming is not needed, but kicking steadily beside a moving shark is. For beginners.
  6. Phones beat cameras. A small action camera, or your phone in a sealed pouch, does the job, and video works better than stills. Filming the shark.
  7. Cabo adds five hours. The day trip is easy but long, with about two and a half hours each way on the road. A night in La Paz changes the maths. Cabo or La Paz.
  8. Sea lions are a second day. The colony at Los Islotes is a separate full-day trip. Doing both on one day makes a very long day. Adding the sea lions.

Everything in one table

Three whale shark swims, catch included

The three tours side by side. Each row sets the strength of a swim against its catch.

Swipe the table sideways to see all columns →

Tour Ideal for Price Length Starts from Tour company and rating Strength and catch Book
Biologist-led small group (our pick) A first swim, families ~$187per person About 4 h Eco Migrations office, Zona Central Eco Migrations
4.9 on GetYourGuide
Full wetsuit, biologist, about 8 per boat. Pricier, no hotel pickup.
Budget 3-hour swim A tight budget ~$123per person About 3 h Muelle Fiscal, Malecón Mexico Travel Adventure
5.0 on both sites
Lowest price, groups of five. No wetsuit listed, no food.
Day trip from Cabo Cabo stays without a car ~$259per person About 10 h Hotel pickup in Los Cabos Cabo Adventures
4.9 on Viator
Pickup, wetsuit, taco lunch. About 5 h on the road, twice the price.

About the numbers. Prices are "from" rates per person in US dollars and can show lower on either site. Dates and exchange rates move them, so check the booking page, which has the final word.

Who went

Reviews from travelers who swam beside one

Fourteen travelers, some who had a shark glide right past their mask and some who fought wind and murky water, on what won them over and what they would do differently.

★★★★★Biologist-led small group

Our guide was a marine biologist who told us on the ride out how to tell a young male from a female by the fins. Then a shark about the length of a minivan glided under me with its mouth open, scooping plankton. The full wetsuit kept me warm through four swims, and there were only six of us in the boat, so nobody was elbowing for space in the water. Best morning of our whole Baja trip.

LRLaura R. · Calgary, CanadaCalm sea
★★★★★Biologist-led small group

Six people, one biologist, three sharks. I came out of the water laughing.

TMTomás M. · Madrid, SpainCalm sea
★★★★☆Biologist-led small group

The wind picked up halfway through and the water turned murky green, so the second swim was short and hard to see in. The guide was clear that the sharks decide the day. Still glad we went, and the office in town was easy to find on foot.

AKAnna K. · Hamburg, GermanyChoppy day
★★★★★Biologist-led small group

I am not a strong swimmer and told the guide so before we left. He stayed next to me the whole time, showed me how to float and kick slowly, and kept us at the right distance. When the shark turned towards us I forgot to be nervous. My wife filmed it all on a phone in a pouch from the boat side.

JPJames P. · Leeds, UKCalm sea
★★★★★Biologist-led small group

Learned more about whale sharks in four hours than in years of documentaries.

MSMei S. · SingaporeCalm sea
★★★★★Biologist-led small group

We booked this one because of the marine biologist, and it showed. Before anyone got in the water she explained the rules in the zone, why you never swim over the head, and why the boats take turns. Out by El Mogote the water was flat and full of plankton, and we had three good swims with a shark that seemed completely unbothered by us. Back at the office by lunchtime, with the whole afternoon free for Balandra.

RBRachel B. · Austin, USACalm sea
★★★★★Budget 3-hour swim

Cheapest one we found and it did not feel cheap. Groups of five in the water, so everyone got a proper look.

DVDaan V. · Utrecht, NetherlandsCalm sea
★★★★★Budget 3-hour swim

Met at the pier on the Malecón, ten minutes later we were at the whale shark area. Our group got four turns in the water, each time with the guide pointing us to where the shark was heading. Bring your own towel and a jacket, the ride back is breezy in the morning.

SCSofia C. · Buenos Aires, ArgentinaCalm sea
★★★★☆Budget 3-hour swim

Great sharks, short trip. I had not packed a wetsuit, and in winter the water felt fresh after the third swim. Bring a rash guard or a shorty if you have one. The guide was friendly and knew exactly what he was doing.

BHBen H. · Melbourne, AustraliaChoppy day
★★★★★Budget 3-hour swim

Short, cheap, and a shark the size of a bus next to me. Perfect morning.

YOYuki O. · Osaka, JapanCalm sea
★★★★★Day trip from Cabo

We were staying in Cabo and did not want to drive ourselves, so this was the easy answer. The van picked us up at the hotel, the drive through the desert went faster than I expected, and the panga ride out to the sharks was short. We swam with two different sharks, then had fish tacos and some time to walk the Malecón. A long day, but nothing for us to organize, and the guides took care of the rest.

CWChris W. · Phoenix, USACalm sea
★★★★★Day trip from Cabo

Ten hours door to door, worth planning around. The tacos at the end were excellent.

ELElena L. · Milan, ItalyCalm sea
★★★★☆Day trip from Cabo

The swim itself was fantastic and the crew handled everyone well, from kids to grandparents. The catch is the road: about two and a half hours each way, and on the return most of us slept. If you have a free night, staying in La Paz and booking a morning trip there would give you more time in the water for less.

MGMarcus G. · Toronto, CanadaChoppy day
★★★★★Day trip from Cabo

My teenage son had been asking for this for years. Pickup from our resort was on time, and the guide checked every life jacket and mask before anyone went in. When the shark came by, my son was right beside it, and the guide had us keep our distance without spoiling the moment. Lunch in La Paz afterwards, then a quiet ride home through the cactus country. Worth the early start from Cabo.

NFNadia F. · Paris, FranceCalm sea

Been already?

Tell the next swimmer how it went

Share your morning in the bay, whether the sharks lined up beside you or kept their distance. We read every review before it goes up, and we publish the critical ones too.

Your rating
The sea that day

At least 40 characters, 40 to go

Mask on

Book Eco Migrations for your whale shark swim

If you are in La Paz between November and April and want one morning beside a whale shark, we would book Eco Migrations. A small boat, a full wetsuit for the cool water, and a marine biologist who swims with you and explains what you are seeing.

Cancelling is free until 24 hours before, so book an early morning of your stay and keep an eye on the wind. Bring a towel and a warm layer for the ride back.

~$187

per person · about 4 hours · from the center of La Paz

  • ✓ Free cancellation up to 24 hours before
  • ✓ Small group, about 8 per boat
  • ✓ Full wetsuit and snorkel kit
  • ✓ Marine biologist guide

Good to know

Why the sharks come to La Paz, and what you are swimming beside

Five minutes of reading makes the first sight of that huge spotted back far less of a shock, and tells you where to look.

The whale shark is the largest fish in the sea, a shark that eats nothing bigger than plankton and small fish. Each winter young ones gather in the bay of La Paz to feed. That puts them a short boat ride from a town of cafés and hotels.

01A sandbar full of food

El Mogote is the long sandy spit that closes off the bay opposite the Malecón. The shallow water beside it fills with plankton in the cooler months, and the sharks follow the food. The bay explained.

02Young sharks, not giants

The sharks here are mostly juveniles, often said to be four to eight meters long. That is still longer than the panga you arrive in. Adults grow far bigger and roam the open ocean. The months they stay.

03A mouth that sieves the sea

A whale shark is a filter feeder. It swims slowly with its wide mouth open and strains the water through its gills. It has no interest in swimmers, and the rules keep swimmers from bothering it. The rules in the zone.

The moment most swimmers remember is the guide shouting "there", a dark shape in the green water, and then a wall of white spots sliding past an arm's length away.

04Hitchhikers and spots

Look along the belly and you may see remoras, small fish that ride on the shark and feed on scraps. The pattern of white spots on each shark is unique, a bit like a fingerprint. Researchers use photos of it to tell individuals apart.

05Manners in the water

Slip in quietly, stay beside the shark rather than in front of it, and keep your distance from the tail. No touching and no flash, even if the shark swims straight at you. Give the other swimmers room for their turn. Filming without a dive camera.

06When the bay says no

Some mornings the wind keeps the boats in port, and some days the sharks spread out and are hard to find. The authorities that manage the area can also limit swims to protect the sharks. If your trip is cancelled, you get a new date or a refund. Plan B.

3–4 hA typical swim from La Paz

Nov to AprThe rough season in the bay

5Swimmers per group on the budget trip

2.5 hThe drive from Cabo San Lucas, each way

Want sea lions as well? Our guide Adding the sea lions of Espíritu Santo shows how to fit both into one stay.

Questions and answers

Frequently asked questions about whale shark tours in La Paz

Fourteen questions we hear again and again, with the full answer.

How much does a whale shark tour in La Paz cost?

The three swims on this page start at ~$123 per person for Mexico Travel Adventure's three-hour trip and ~$187 for Eco Migrations' small group with a biologist. The day trip from Los Cabos with Cabo Adventures costs ~$259 with pickup and lunch. Prices move with the date. Every price and extra is in our cost guide.

Which whale shark tour in La Paz is the best?

For most visitors, Eco Migrations' swim, because it keeps the group small, lends a full wetsuit and has a marine biologist in the water with you. The Mexico Travel Adventure swim suits budget travelers, and Cabo Adventures suits people staying in Los Cabos without a car.

When is whale shark season in La Paz?

The sharks are usually in the bay from about November to April, when the young ones gather to feed on plankton. Some operators start in mid-October. December to February are usually the strongest months. The season in detail.

How long is a whale shark tour?

From La Paz, about three to four hours from the start to being back on land. Coming from Los Cabos with Cabo Adventures fills a day of about ten hours, with the drive and lunch.

Are whale sharks guaranteed?

No. They are wild animals, and some days they are hard to find or the wind keeps the boats in port. In season the odds are good, but no listing can promise a sighting. What happens if you see none.

Is it safe to swim with whale sharks?

Yes, for the swimmer. Whale sharks eat plankton and show no interest in people. The main risks are a knock from the tail if you get too close and tiredness in the water, which is why the guides keep groups small and set the distance.

Do I need to be a strong swimmer?

No, but you should be comfortable floating with a mask and snorkel. Wetsuits and life vests add buoyancy, and the guide swims with you. Practising in a pool first helps. Kids and beginners.

Can children swim with whale sharks?

Often yes, with a parent and a life vest, but each listing sets its own limits and some exclude babies. Check the age rules before you book. Eco Migrations' small group and biologist guide make it the easiest choice for families.

What are the rules in the whale shark area?

Small groups in the water with a guide, a few meters' distance from the shark, no touching, no flash, no scuba, and boats taking turns. The guides brief you before you get in. The rules explained.

What should I bring on a whale shark tour?

A swimsuit under your clothes, a towel, a windproof layer for the ride back, reef-safe sunscreen or a rash guard, a hat and some cash for tips. A phone in a waterproof pouch is enough for photos. The packing list.

Can I do a whale shark tour from Cabo San Lucas?

You can. Cabo Adventures collects you from your Los Cabos hotel and drives about two and a half hours each way to La Paz, with lunch included. Staying a night in La Paz is cheaper and gives you a spare morning. Cabo or La Paz.

Where do the boats leave from?

From the waterfront of La Paz. The budget swim gathers at the Muelle Fiscal pier on the Malecón; Eco Migrations starts at its office in the center and takes you to the boat. The whale shark area is a short ride across the bay.

Can I see sea lions on the same trip?

Not on the three tours here. The sea lions live at Los Islotes, a rocky islet north of Espíritu Santo, and seeing them takes a separate full-day boat trip. Most visitors do it on another day. Adding the sea lions.

Can I cancel a whale shark tour for free?

Yes. All three can be cancelled free of charge up to 24 hours before on GetYourGuide. If wind or a port closure stops the boats, the operator offers a new date or your money back.

Read before you travel

Guides to swimming with whale sharks

Ten questions that keep coming up, each with the long answer instead of the short one.